18 Best Halloween Cookie Cutters for 2024: Scary-Good Baking Fun

This impressive set of Halloween cookie cutters gives you a wide array of unique shapes to choose from, including vampire fangs, a spider, and a skull-and-crossbones. It even includes a rolling pin to keep your cookie dough smooth!

They’re also safer and easier for young kids to handle since they are bordered in grippy plastic.

More: The Best Pumpkin-Carving Kits You Can Buy on Amazon

We solemnly swear we’re up to no good … but these goodies are delicious! This Harry Potter-themed set of Halloween cookie cutters displays classic shapes that will be instantly recognizable to any true Potterhead: Hedwig the owl, the Sorting Hat, and Harry’s Nimbus 2000.

This ghost-shaped cookie cutter is your shortcut to one frightfully good snack table. If you like your Halloween treats sweet and not scary, this is a great pick for a kid-friendly spread.

This fun Halloween cookie-cutter set comes with five different shapes, including a witchy hat, a scary ghost, a classic pumpkin, and a cat. If you can’t decide on just one shape for Halloween, get ’em all! This set is perfect for crafts and kids’ parties.

For deadly delicious treats at any Halloween-themed party or haunted house, check out this Day of the Dead-inspired skull cookie cutter. It’s perfect for making colorful sugar-skull treats!

For cookies that are sure to send your guests into a coffin fit of excitement, scoop up this creepy coffin-shaped cookie cutter ASAP. It can even be used to cut craft clay and soft fruits, too.

Bonus points if you pair these with cute little vampire cookies on your plate!

There’s no question that we look forward to Halloween treats all year round — but what about when October 31st has come and gone? This enormous set of 101 cookie cutters has you covered for the other 364 days in a year.

It features eight Halloween-specific shapes like a haunted house, witch’s head, and black cat, but it also has numbers, the entire alphabet, and shapes for other holidays, too! You can even reach for this set when Christmas, Valentine’s Day, Easter, July 4th, and your birthday rolls around.

…And speak of the devil! It’s hard not to get charmed by this kid-friendly iteration of our fave classic bloodsucker (I mean, cutest fangs ever?). You can choose between small (2 inches) to giant (7 inches) and just the stamp or stencil or both.

This fun assortment features iconic Halloween monsters that your kids will love, from a mummy to a zombie and even Frankenstein! Each one is a set in itself that measures around 12 inches and is made up of separate body part outlines — at $30 for the entire set, it’s such great value!

We’re absolutely batty over this fun, sturdy, and easy-to-use Halloween cookie cutter. It comes in different sizes (small/1.5 inches to jumbo/6 inches), so you can choose from different options.

Try baking a batch of plain, bat-shaped cookies for your next Halloween party, and let your guests decorate their own custom treats.

If you’re throwing a Dracula- or vamp-themed monster ball, this original fang cutter is simply, well, fang-tabulous! It has a bit of that ’80s horror-trope charm (color the lips in different reds or neons for a saturated feel) and is a quirkier take on traditional Halloween iconography.

For those wanting a more unique adult take, these iconic movie villain cookie cutters serve up some authentic Halloween scaries to your dessert table. Choose from Friday the 13th‘s Jason, Nightmare on Elm Street‘s Freddy Krueger, the Scream‘s hooded antagonist, Halloween‘s Michael Myers — or get the entire gruesome foursome in an assorted set.

Can’t get enough? The seller also has adorable Ghostbusters and Nightmare Before Christmascookie cutters for sale. Make your next party a movie-themed affair!

Whether your cookie dough is storebought or homemade, everyone who is served these cookies will ask you how you did it. The answer? With these genius plunger molds, of course!

Just roll out your dough, line up the stamp, and press down the plunger to make your mark while cutting the design from the dough. Also, this might be the cutest grim reaper we’ve ever seen… just saying.

Bring the pumpkin patch indoors with these fun and festive cookie cutters inspired by everyone’s favorite autumnal squash. Deck out your cookies with bright orange frosting, glitter, and spooky eyes for the ultimate jack-o’-lantern-inspired dessert.

Even if you’re superstitious about black cats, you won’t be able to resist these absolutely purr-fect cat-shaped cookie cutters. This three-piece set features a cat face shape, a sitting cat, and a curled cat for some fun variety.

Because candy corn is basically synonymous with the scariest of all holidays, celebrate those colorful and nostalgic (and, yup, polarizing!) candies with this candy corn-inspired cookie cutter.

Play around with yellow, orange, and white frosting, and add real candy corn bits to your cookies for the full effect!

Crafted from heavy-duty, tin-plated steel, this cauldron-shaped Halloween cookie cutter is perfect for any magical gathering. You can get pretty creative with how you want to color, shape, and decorate the bubbling brew inside.

You’re sure to have the most sinister spread in town with this bone-shaped cookie cutter, perfect for a skeleton-inspired cookie batch — no bones about it!

Plus, after the scary season is over, you can also use it for other puppy or dog-themed treats.